Ask the Veterinary Nutritionist

Do you have a specific question related to pet nutrition?

Our database contains over 1200 questions asked by pet owners and veterinarians.  Enter a search term, then use the "topic" filter if you would like to narrow your search further.  If you don't find an answer here, submit your question and a nutritionist will respond to your questions as best possible. Email responses will come from

We believe pets make us better people.
Donations provide nutritional consultations to disabled military and seniors citizens with sick pets.
If you wish to make a contribution for the information you have received, please click to donate.

Thank you for your contribution!

  • I would like to know what your opinion is of the Kirkland dog foods sold by Costco. Both grain free and with grain. They are manufactured by Diamond. They appear to be good products and are certainly cost effective. I usually stick with Purina due to the feeding trials, but the Costco food is tempting. Would like your thoughts. Thank you!
  • The Diamond Manufactured products have appear too often on the FDA Pet food recall list for my liking.
    Grain / no grain is irrelevant to canine nutrition. It is simply another marketing ploy.

  • I am a veterinarian looking for information to provide my client. My client has a 10 week goldendoodle who is estimated to be 25# at full maturity. The dame was 75#, and the sire was 5# (yes this is correct information). Their breeder insists that this 5#, 10 week old puppy be fed a large breed diet. Do you have an opinion on this? I have advised that they switch to a regular puppy food. I want to make sure I am not overlooking something with this breeder's recommendation. I cannot find any information on feeding a large breed formula to a small-medium sized dog. Any help is greatly appreciated!
  • It has been generally accepted that large breed dogs have a mature weight of 65 lbs or more.

    So I would agree a Large Breed Growth diet is not necessary - probably harmless to feed - but not necessary.

    There are some growth studies comparing large breed puppies with small size poodle puppies and there were very few (if any) clinical signs in the poodles, hence growth rate and weight were thought to be a major players in the problem.

  • My 11 yr old sheltie has been tested for hyperthyroidism and cushings disease and is negative yet his cholesterol and triglyceride levels are almost triple what they should be.He is not overweight (24 lbs) his coat is shiny and thick, does not drink water excessively, is not lethargic, actually has no symptoms. My vet is perplexed and suggested diet is to blame but he has been on Science Diet low fat ID for several months. Without changing anything the triglycerides came down and then went back up. I'm hoping to find a diet that might help. Please suggest a food that may help. I'm not a fan of the Science diet because of the ingredients.
  • If the TG were measured on a 12-18 hr fasted blood sample and near or above 500, then you should modify the diet.

    The cholesterol levels are not clinically significant in the dog. You need only be concerned about the TGs.


    Hill's make several "i/d" products

    If you were feeding HIll's i/d LOW FAT, there is no other product lower in fat.

    Royal Canin makes a GI LOW FAT but it contains the same level as the Hill's i/d LOW FAT.


    Your only next option if the TGs were greater than 500 on a 12-18 hr fasted blood sample, is to feed an ultra-low homemade diet, and we can formulate one for you through our Nutrition Consult Service.

    If the levels re between normal and 500 and the dog has never had an episode of pancreatitis, you may continue to feed the i/d LOW FAT and opt to simply recheck the dog in 6 months.....

    There is nothing bad about the ingredients in the Hill'd i/d and I would not want you to be scared off the right food for the dog based on popular internet myths regarding dog food ingredients.

  • What's the best kibble for a 11-12 lbs mini poodle mix female, almost 9 years old? No health issues (possibly soy or beef itchiness but not confirmed in light of possible environmental allergens, and prone to constipation) but I was curious about Science Diet or Purina, or else wise, for healthy aging. I understand they make cognitive function support formulas. I don't know which is the most researched, and also, she's dainty and doesn't handle medium sized kibble well, even though I fully hydrate before feeding it. She has dental damage from her past life, but I brush daily, don't need dental kibble for that.

    Currently I give Petcurean Now! Senior for petite breeds (she's a lazy girl, don't want to go high on calories). Egg is high on the ingredient list, but turkey is higher. I would prefer fatty fish over turkey for omegas (with egg in it as well). The main fatty acid sources are coconut oil (ever the fad) and canola oil. I don't know how well those stack up against fatty fish but am concerned about companies tending to use over harvested species like menhaden. I'd like to avoid josh species under pressure.

    I don't care about price and I actually prefer grains, which the Petcurean and SO MUCH else omits these days.
    I'd like to be able to feed a sizable quantity to keep her feeling full rather than nutrient concentrated tiny amounts.
    Any pointers, please?
  • I would suggest you try:, and see what Purina comes up with specific for your dog.
    This site should be able to cater to your needs and you'll benefit from the decades of research experience Purina has to offer.
    Let me know if this does not work for you.
  • RE: Purina's purchase of Merrick pet foods (which includes a few other brands), a pet food company that touts a "holistic" lineup of dog and cat foods.

    I'm no longer taken in by slogans like "natural" and "holistic" but would like to have more food choices for my cats. As a consumer on behalf of my cats, variety appeals to me.
    Now, I stick with those pet foods that are commercially formulated by on-staff animal nutritionists like as yourself. Purina is currently the mainstay of what I buy for my pride. Science Diet and Royal Canin are just not affordable on my multi-cat household budget. My choices are further self-limited, however, because I don't feed any of the Purina formulas that contain fish.

    I always avoid cat foods from companies like Merrick. Now that Purina owns them, do you think Purina will oversee the Merrick formulas for nutritional soundness, etc. and make any necessary changes as per nutritional science and not marketing hype? If the price point is reasonable, I would have more foods to pick from for my kitties.

  • As I see it ..... Purina prides itself on excellent nutrition while saying one size food does not fit all pets and does not fit all owners preferences, so they are at the top when it comes to providing options after first providing sound nutritional value.

    So Merrick products bring yet another slate of options to accomodate the many different pet owner perferences, and yes if the current products do not fit Purina's nutritional criteria, then changes will be made to bring those products into line while not changing the "apparent" options Merrick offered. 


    The "Merrick" line of products may be discontinued - swallowed up and will disappear from the market place b/c one successful ploy in a competitive field of business is to simply buy out your competitor and make them go away. 

    I really cannot tell you which way it will go ....


  • My question is about carbohydrates and their role in food allergies. Correct me if I'm wrong, but there is protein in carbs and that is what the dog reacts to? Now if that is true, will the dog only react if within the ingredient list you find, wheat gluten, corn gluten, pea protein, potato protein etc...or if they are sensitive to one of those ingredients they will react to the carb in it's whole form because of the protein fraction in it?

    For example, my dogs get treats with wheat flour, however the dog with food allergies (diganosed by food trial with RC Hydrolyzed Protein) seems to react to the Pro Plan tubbed wet food that contains wheat gluten, but not these treats. His symptoms include; red mouth, acne like bumps around his mouth, red/raw inbetween his digits, yeast build-up under his nail beds and inbetween his digits and constant paw licking. We stopped the Pro Plan tubbed food and went back to the normal canned food he gets which is the same variety as the dry (Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach) and the red digit and mouth went away.
  • In food allergy, the problem is with the protein fraction and yes grains do contain some (less than 10% protein). The immune system does not react to carb, fat, fiber, vitamin or a mineral - only a protein.
    Yes the gluten form of a grain as an ingredient in pet foods is a concentration form of the grain protein added to provide the essential sulfur amino acids that are lacking in meat proteins.

    Wheat flour is predominately (90%) starch which does not cause an allergic reaction but wheat protein fraction can cause an allergic reaction.  In RC HP, only the soybean protein has been hydrolyzed but the potato protein is whole. In the Hill’s z/d Ultra .... the protein source chicken liver has been hydrolyzed and the carb source is 'corn starch' - so the corn protein fraction was omitted. So yes, the grain ingredient does bring in protein, usually very small, glutens are concentrated grain protein ingredients which can cause a response from the immune system.

  • Hi, I recently purchased two recipes from you for my 12 year old mini dachshund. One was beef/rice/veggie 35% protein, 20% fat, 4% fiber and the other is chicken thigh/sweet potato/veggie with 31% protein, 9%fat, 8% fiber (isn't that very high carbs). The recipes are so varied in the nutritional ratio content, could you explain why? My main concern is making sure my senior dog has a healthy as diet as possible, what are the main objectives I should have when feeding him a homemade diet? Protein/ fat/ carbs/ fiber etc.? I am using the Balanceit supplement. Thank you so much for taking time to answer my questions.
  • The nutrient profile difference between these 2 recipes is actually quite small in protein. The fat varies depending on whether you want/requested high, low or moderate calorie content. The fiber content will vary depending on whether you want/requested high, low or moderate fiber content. The carb amount then completes the remaining percent which can vary between 20-80%. There is no carb minimum or maximum recommendation unless the dog has diabetes. The % protein, fat and fiber best for your dog depends on many factors such as body condition score and most recent blood work. If you need or would like a personalized nutritional recommendation, I can do that through our Nutrition Consultation Service.

  • I have 2 8 month old goldendoodle puppies. After 2 months of frustrating diarrhea we found out One of them has an intolerance to chicken so I have been feeding them Nature's Variety Limited Ingredient. I love the food however the price has increased twice and the bags have gotten smaller and local pet stores are no longer selling the rabbit flavor because of how quickly it expires. I would like to look into another brand that does the rotational diet and would be a good fit. A few people have suggested Zignature but i have read reviews that it causes dogs to defecate 4-5 times a day in large quantities. (Mine poop twice a day and somewhat small amount for being 65 lbs). Our other dog eats Fromm and I love that brand however they don't have a limited ingredient line. I've read through some of their 4 star flavored and there are a few that don't contain chicken. Would they be ok with these foods or should I just stick with NVLID?
    I'm so overwhelmed with all of the options and reviews!
  • The good news is that reading ‘reviews’ about a food fed to a different dog is not the best way to select a dogfood. If your dog is truly chicken intolerant and should not eat any chicken products, then you should not feed any OTC dog food because they are not clean enough. Limited ingredient dog foods are still "contaminated" with other ingredients in the processing system - but not on the label. This has been clearly demonstrated in half a dozen studies from as many different researchers in both the US and Europe. It is not even a debatable point any more. So you will have to first decide how important it is to you and your dog that you avoid chicken ....

    If very important ... then you will have to feed a food from the Veterinary Therapeutic Line of food b/c they are produced (plant shut down for an 8 hr cleaning schedule between different products), tested (ELISA and PCR) and guaranteed (sold to Vets) to be clean of contaminates. Examples are Hill's d/d line or Royal Canin Hypoallergenic line ... these foods cost more because of this guarantee.

    If not so important and you are willing to put up with the occasional contaminated food  and the diarrhea (usually occurs after opening a new bag), then continue to read labels and select a product that does not contain chicken or poultry ingredients from a company that makes THIER OWN FOOD, and does NOT use chicken or poultry products in any of their other dog food products. If a manufacturer does not make their own food but has it made for them (90% of pet food manufacturers) then you cannot assess if poultry ingredients are in the plant because you would have to review every body’s product line made at that plant = impossible.

    Ignore the reviews by self-appointed "dog food experts" and those that have made up their own "evaluation or rating" system .... all are bogus, misdirected, misleading and causing more confusion than clarity.
  • How would it be if I read your entire 1000+ question web site to research my dog's food choices, only to wind up feeding him Dog Chow? Do people routinely have to defend themselves against people who assume they are uneducated because they are feeding a common but unfashionable food? Will future breeders reject my puppy application if my current dog is eating Dog Chow?
  • How would it be if I read your entire 1000+ question web site to research my dog's food choices, only to wind up feeding him Dog Chow?
    You would not be the first.

    Do people routinely have to defend themselves against people who assume they are uneducated because they are feeding a common but unfashionable food?
    Yes .. if you read some of these FAQ you will hear the same frustrations.

    Will future breeders reject my puppy application if my current dog is eating Dog Chow?
    Well breeders already take the liberty of dictating what your dog can be fed ..... so yes it might happen.

  • I have a female dog who has been diagnosed with struvite stones. please can you tell me what tit bits I can use for training purposes?

  • Anything you want .... struvite in the dog is caused by a urinary tract infection .... which is an antibiotic deficiency and not a dietary issue.
1245 Results Found FirstPrevious 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22Next   Page 17 of 125