Ask the Veterinary Nutritionist

Do you have a specific question related to pet nutrition?

Our database contains nearly 1000 questions asked by other pet owners and veterinarians. Enter a search term, then use the "topic" filter if you would like to narrow your search further.

If you don't find an answer here, please submit your question. An ACVN Board Certified Veterinary Nutritionist (PhD, DVM, DACVN) will directly respond to your questions as best as possible.

Submit Question

Is there someone, even for a fee, that can analyze what I am feeding my dog and tell me if it is deficient is any way?
Please know that if you concocted your own homemade diet or obtained it from a book or off the net from someone who is not a veterinary nutritionist, there is a 95% chance the diet is not nutritionally complete and balanced according to a 2013 UC Davis study https://www.ucdavis.edu/news/homemade-dog-food-recipes-can-be-risky-business-study-finds/.

You have several options:

1.     We can analyze your homemade recipe and correct it for $350 – includes nutrient corrections

2.     You can send it off to the Lab for the full (~32 nutrient) AAFCO profile for $2500 – does not include nutrient corrections

3.     You can send it off to a Lab for a partial (~10 nutrient) profile for $50 - does not include nutrient corrections

4.     You can purchase a recipe online where you select the ingredients close to what you are currently feeding for $25 is correct from the start.

Are you familiar with Young Again cat food? I am looking to feed my 3 month old kitten the next best to a homemade diet. Right now I do a half can of Instinct wet kitten food in the morning and Young Again ZERO kibble as “free choice”, monotoring to make sure his intake doesn’t exceed the recommended amount. It’s an incredibly nutrient dense dry food with a lot of claims of illness prevention and even reversal (urine crystals, diabetes, etc.). My weary feeling is in just how high the protein content is, the trace carbohydrate content (I understand cats are obligate carnivores) and the small “mom & pop” company. I’ve done ALOT of research and this is the food I chose for many reasons. I’m just looking for a professional opinion on the adequacy of meeting my kittens nutritional needs and carrying him through his adult life. Here is a direct web address to the ZERO variety of food that I am feeding: https://www.youngagainpetfood.com/phone/zero-formula.html
Your insight and opinion is much appreciated. Many Thanks, Amanda
This statement indicates the food on paper meets AAFCO recommendations for growth and adult maintenance.

"Young Again is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Cat Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages."

Apparently the food has not been fed in any actual feeding trials so your cat is a test.
It is very energy dense which is what happens when you provide calories as fat and not carbs ... so most adult cats will become fat on this diet unless fed restricted amounts despite their claims. And if the cat becomes obese (no matter how that happens), the risk of diabetes is high, which of course again runs counter to their claim. I cannot tell you any more than that.

I am looking for a good puppy food for an 8-week old Pomsky that doesn’t contain any fish or fish oils as my wife is allergic and breaks out into hives when licked. We want to feed him with the best!
This is no small task given the importance.
If you would like us to work up a search proposal, I'd be glad to do so.
Will you not also need an adult food?

In the comment section below it was answered to someone that dogs cannot get all the nutrients that they need only from homemade food, hence they need supplements. I have a hard time thinking it may be so, then wild dogs and wolves that live and feed in nature are malnourished?
Thanks.
Yes mostly ... the diet need only minimally support them to meet their evolutionary duty - reproduce and that can be done by 18-24 months of age. So the hit or miss diet need only meet that low standard.

Today people want their dogs to live "forever", disease free and thrive, so the demands on the dietary intake to meet these goals is very different than their ancestors and feral canines.

Actually, what I say is that no one can meet AAFCO, NRC or FEDIAF daily recommended nutrient intakes in a homemade diet without using supplements. So now you have to decide if these 3 independent canine nutrient think tanks know what they are talking about when it comes to daily nutrient intakes that promote wellbeing in dogs through 15-20 yrs of life.

Important to note: none of these 3 organizations have a food or supplement to sell you.

I have been told large breed puppy food can be bad for my dane puppy. People tell me to switch to adult food saying the puppy food is too high in protein.
Should I stick with diamond large breed puppy, or switch to the adult brand.
15 week's. Male greatdane/stbernard mix.
Thank you!
1. Protein intake is not the problem with Developmental Bone Diseases in large breed dogs .... so these "people" are about 20 yrs out of date.
2. Yes stick with a large breed puppy food because the problem is really Calcium intake and AAFCO has set the maximum at 1.8% Ca on a dry matter basis to help protect these growing dogs.
3. Adult brands actually contain too much calcium when you do the math correctly based on calorie intake, so that is not advisable until 12-15 months of age.

Why is iodine added to canned cat food? I currently feed my 2 cats First Mate canned cat food but the carbs on a caloric value are 19%. I am thinking of switching to Rawz but I see they also add iodine. Can you review the ingredients in Rawz, see below and let me know if this food is safe to feed. It is AFFCO approved and my 2.5 yr old kitties are healthy so far.
INGREDIENT: Chicken, Chicken Liver, Chicken Broth, Fenugreek Seeds, Natural Flavor, Potassium Chloride, Choline Chloride, Calcium Carbonate, Salt, Vegetable Broth, Taurine, Tricalcium Phosphate, Zinc Proteinate, Iron Proteinate, Niacin Supplement, Vitamin E Supplement, Copper Proteinate, Sodium Selenite, Thiamine Mononitrate, Manganese Proteinate, Vitamin A Supplement, Calcium Pantothenate, Riboflavin Supplement, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Biotin, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Ethylenediamine Dihydroiodide, Folic Acid.
Why is iodine added to canned cat food? AAFCO requires a minimum amount of iodine in cat food and so if there is not a sufficient amount coming from the ingredients, regulations require that it be added.

and let me know if this food is safe to feed?

'Safety' depends on the manufacturer following good manufacturing procedures, which is NO where on the pet food label.
If you are asking are the ingredients 'safe to feed' ......... yes unless the manufacturer is in violation of AAFCO regulations which specifies which ingredients can be used in cat foods. Only approved ingredients may be used.

I am feeding my 11year old lab a homemade diet of ground beef or chicken, brown rice, pumpkin, green beans, chicken giblets,livers,hearts,some sardines and sweet potatoes. He also gets 2 vetri science senior multivitamins, 1 standard process Renatrophin, 1 1/2 cosaquin ds tabs. He is also on 500 mg 2 x a day of ciproflaxin for a cut tendon from 6 years ago. It is the only thing that keeps the infection away. He weighs about 86 lbs. takes I long walk and 1 or 2 short walks a day. Can still jump on the bed. Can you tell me how much I should feed him? Thank you so much for your help.
Despite feeding all those expensive supplements, it appears that the diet as you have described it is not complete or balanced. If your pet has no medical issues, we have an automated module for owners to obtain a balanced diet for their healthy pet.

Can you tell me how much I should feed him?

Go to www.petdiets.com. You begin the process by logging into your account or opening an account for you, your pet and link it to your Vet info, then click on 'Services:’ drop down to “Homemade Diet Recipes’. Select the “See all ingredient options” to see all of our food options or one of several specific diet types (high or low calorie, etc.). You may select ingredients similar to those you are now feeding. The software will re-balance your diet properly, suggest a single vitamin & trace mineral supplement and give you the recommended daily food intake. The cost is $25 for the first recipe and $12 for each thereafter purchased at the same time. Recipes are available for immediate download after payment.

Thank you for visiting PetDIETS.com!

I am trying very hard to home cook for my dog without supplements because I feel you can get all the supplements you need right in actual food. Wd you give me a simple outline that wd fit all requirements for a total diet for our dog. Thank you. One simple recipe wd help.
Sorry although you may 'feel' it should be possible, one cannot meet the current AAFCO, NRC or FEDIAF daily canine requirements for all 35+ nutrients in the proper concentration to energy and/or ratio to each other with a vitamin mineral supplement. I have tried to do it for 30+ yrs using all 8000+ nutrients in the USDA human nutrition database, so I am pretty confident it cannot be done.

For example, the average 30 lb would have to eat 43 medium apples or 2 lbs of carrots every day just to meet 3 of the known essential vitamins. So vegetable and fruits do contain vitamins and trace minerals, but in very low concentrations. .... too low to meet the daily recommended requirement in a reasonable amount of food a dog can consume in one day.

My 2 6 and 8 year old indoor/outdoor farm cats get fed Nutrisource 1/4 C BID and a few kibbles of Science Diet TD daily.(treats are only of these 2 options as well and not many (most are taken from their daily allotment. (A third cat is on KD).The overweight cats are active outdoors by request as soon as good weather hits but are currently over (weight-13.4 lbs) and have been gaining a pound or 2 each year recently. ( They do try to sneak the leftover KD from the third cat and we minimize that as much as possible.) Science Diet (SD) Light was recommended by my vet for their weight loss.

Is it really the bet choice for weight loss? My concern is that every vet I have ever used (6) recommends Science Diet and usually mentions that they and feed it to their pets.
Is it because they have been indoctrinated by SD in vet school or is it really a premium safe product? I have concerns about the parent company and its need to make quarterly returns!
When I ask the vets this question they talk about how they have been to the SD facility etc.and of course, it is for sale in every office.
What's the options?

Only 4 companies make foods for feline medical conditions and only a vet can prescribed that food. If they do not carry the food in their office, you would have to order it online. Either way it is not in a grocery store or pet shop (unless they are affiliated with a licensed vet) and never will be. Most vets carry some so the patient can get started on the right food, but you could always ask for a script and go the online option. Some vets do not carry food and simply give them a script and leave it up to them get .....

Yes every company has to make the finances work but food sales for vets has a very small margin of profit, takes up a lot of retail space and usually some employee has lug that stuff in and then out of the office. It is not the best or easiest way for the office to make a dollar. Most do it for owner convenience and according to large surveys, most pet owner want a dietary recommendation from the vet but then get upset when it is not their favorite brand …. We can’t win really but we continue to try to make the best recommendations possible for the pet.

Science Diet Light (red label) is a weight management food, not a weight loss food, and you can find it in pet stores, etc and get it without a script. So if you buy it from the vet directly, that is your choice. But know there is a difference between weight management and weight loss diets, and you'll have to discuss that with the pet's primary care vet. True weight loss foods are sold by prescription only. The Hill’s Prescription line (blue label) for feline weight loss is w/d or r/d.

I assure you that ALL four companies that sell medical diets are in the vets schools demonstrating their products to students. Same as with vaccine, drug and equipment companies, book vendors and potential employers. This is no different than medical, dental or nursing school. AND no pet food company is paying anyone's Veterinary School debt off in return for selling thier food. Yes all 4 companies regularly bring in veterinary groups to their plants to demonstrate exactly how the food is made, ingredient quality control, production processes and discuss feeding philosophies. It is the primary reason why most vets are not part of the mass hysteria over the latest pet food trend, marketing blitz or ingredient craze.

When you think about it really ….. your veterinarian is probably only person with your pets’ best interest in mind because they’ll have your business only as long as you believe they are doing right by your pet.

My 14 y/o bichon was diagnosed with early kidney disease over a year ago. He went on Hills kd dry. He did not like it very much. In the fall, he had several teeth pulled and I switched him to canned. He seemed to like this until recently when he began not finishing any meal. I must work and have no one to help feed him 3-4 smaller meals. My vet said he could have an acid stomach and has put him on Pepcid (1/4 of 10 mg tablet) per day and said to switch him to a bland diet until his stomach settled.
I saw a recipe for food for renal disease https://topdogtips.com/homemade-dog-food-for-kidney-disease-recipe/. He loves this.
Is there anything from a nutritional standpoint that should be added. Vitamins, etc?
Yes there is .... Please be careful with your sick dog. There is not one veterinary nutritionist listed as part of the team.